Fishbowl

Related to my extend the conversation post and my recent conversations with one Mr. Andrew Keen about his upcoming book, The Cult of the Amateur, and a random survey of people in NYC last night, wherein which I asked them some questions (Do you know what Twitter is? Do you know what podcasts are? Can you name a podcast?), I’m still convinced that we’re in a complete and utter fishbowl.

This might not be bad.

I think the trick is this: we’re VERY much where the old web world was, when people were logging on, creating Geocities accounts, and trying to learn how to change the background from olive to yellow. I think blogging is getting much closer to mainstream, especially as almost all the mainstream media outlets have succumbed and built their own blogs. This, by extension, gives us even more of a chance to make a difference and build our own blogs into something of quality.

Learn the Tools

There’s still time to hone your abilities, to pick up some technical knowledge and understanding of these tools. I’d say that if you’re just thinking of jumping in to this part, audio is probably already too far gone. Too many people are out there helping folks get audio shows together. Video might be the right curve to jump into.

Create PROGRAMS

In almost no time, “talking about nothing” shows are going to dry up. You have to deliver value. In video, audio, and even a blog, if you want to bring your message into a larger circle of people, you’re going to have to give value back for what you’re doing. “Catblogging” (talking about your day, random links, funny video clips) will forever be okay for blogs/podcasts/videoblogs that aren’t particularly targeted or aiming to reach a huge audience. (And sure, there are some famous people who pretty much catblog, even if they’re on TV, but we’re not them- yet).

Spend some time making your “product” better. Think of it that way. Ask yourself relentlessly, “Does this appeal to the people I’m hoping to reach?”

Outreach

If we want out of the fishbowl, we have to scale the shiny clear walls. There are ways besides sending emails and posting to forums to reach new people for an audience, ways completely outside the computer. These vary for your demographic of choice. But for instance, if you’re a financial aid podcast, you might contact all the financial aid advisors and guidance counselors in all directions (That’s what Christopher S. Penn did). If you’re a show about gardening, you might swing by the local garden store or join a local club, and find opportunities to talk about your show, or better still, invite guests.

Gather

If you’re in new media and you’re not seeing my prediction from May of 2006 about content networks being the new blogs coming true, look again. PodTech and PodShow and Next New Networks are just some examples of groups of content producers gathering together to build stronger branding. Some are successful, and others are just trying their damnedest to figure it all out. But they’re together, and that’s building an awareness that isn’t there for many standalone applications.

Build Platforms

Your standalone success is one thing, but building a content network where you can empower an audience to truly interact with your media – to contribute, to partner with, to build something out of – that’s where the secret sauce will be. Without it, you’re yet another property without a lot of audience-building tools built in.

Fish Should Stay In Bowls

There are lots of people who think new media / social media are doing just fine by its own. Perhaps that’s true. Perhaps we should just let things stay the same. Verizon and Comcast want you to stop making video shows, because it’s too tricky for them to deal with you. They need things in big bunches, not a grape at a time. Newspapers want you to stop. You’re eating into their attention trust. Magazines are annoyed they have to blog. They’re sick of the format. It’s nothing like their previous systems.

So just stop. Stop making media. Leave it to the pros. Right? There’s a reason reality TV is all over the place. It’s easy. Doesn’t take a writer, really. (Yes, someone writes the shows, I know, but pffff).

Or not

Or you can make the best damned media you can make, strive to get out of that fishbowl, and reach out to the people who need you, who want you to find them and save them from enduring the same old thing. You can bring the message inside you to the people who need to hear it most.

Which is it? What’s your choice? How will you get out of the fishbowl?

Photo credit jaboobie

Related posts:

  1. Interviewed by MediaBistro in the Fishbowl

ChrisBrogan.com runs on the Genesis Framework

Genesis Theme Framework

The Genesis Framework empowers you to quickly and easily build incredible websites with WordPress. Whether you're a novice or advanced developer, Genesis provides you with the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that takes WordPress to places you never thought it could go.

With automatic theme updates and world-class support included, Genesis is the smart choice for your WordPress website or blog.

Become a StudioPress Affiliate

  • kat

    What if all of the current vloggers/bloggers etc etc
    are just clearing the way,
    setting things up for the next wave.

    you do all the pre-work
    establish the medium
    then step aside for the most part
    forced or not
    for the new creators

    are you still willing to put in the work and effort
    if you don’t benefit from it directly?

  • http://nada kat

    What if all of the current vloggers/bloggers etc etc
    are just clearing the way,
    setting things up for the next wave.

    you do all the pre-work
    establish the medium
    then step aside for the most part
    forced or not
    for the new creators

    are you still willing to put in the work and effort
    if you don’t benefit from it directly?

  • http://www.christopherspenn.com Christopher S. Penn

    Kat:

    That’s assuming you just roll over and let them. If you stop paddling, the tidal wave will sink you. But if you develop skill, speed, and agility, you can ride whatever waves come along.

    Surf’s up. It’s our game to lose.

  • http://www.christopherspenn.com Christopher S. Penn

    Kat:

    That’s assuming you just roll over and let them. If you stop paddling, the tidal wave will sink you. But if you develop skill, speed, and agility, you can ride whatever waves come along.

    Surf’s up. It’s our game to lose.

  • http://gardenfork.tv eric : gardenfork.tv

    at lunch yesterday with Grace Piper of fearlesscooking.tv, we asked the young waitperson if she knew what twitter was and she didn’t.

    good point about reaching out beyond the compouter. i am looking for opportunities to talk about my gardening show, as most of my viewers don’t read blogs or yahoo groups, they watch cable tv.

  • http://gardenfork.tv eric : gardenfork.tv

    at lunch yesterday with Grace Piper of fearlesscooking.tv, we asked the young waitperson if she knew what twitter was and she didn’t.

    good point about reaching out beyond the compouter. i am looking for opportunities to talk about my gardening show, as most of my viewers don’t read blogs or yahoo groups, they watch cable tv.

  • http://www.sassyscience.com (Sassy) Sonya Buyting

    I hear what you’re saying about the audio vs. video podcasting. While my audio Sassy Science show (science + music = Sassy) is my bread ‘n’ butter when it comes to my online creative content, I’ve also put out one video. (Only 1 under the Sassy Science banner.) That video generates more comments than any of my audio shows do. I’ve been trying to figure out why. The video is shorter. That makes it easier to digest in a bite size chunk. It is also zany, so that could be an easy explanation. Maybe it’s the YouTube influence that makes people search out video before audio. Or maybe it’s something more shallow that make people seek out the video before audio? I don’t know.

    It still surprises me how many people don’t know that audio podcasts are essentially radio shows available on demand via the Internet. That makes me think that while the word “podcast” has reached the mainstream, many still don’t know what the heck it is. Is this bubble going to break? My hope is that if we keep pushing and if people keep buying their mp3 players, then maybe one day everyone will be downloading their favourite user created content since there’s so much great stuff out there.

    Mainstream TV is looking for the best online video delivery systems. Internet TV is taking off regardless of the mainstream. What does this mean for the future of video & audio podcasting? Who knows. Anyone?

  • http://www.sassyscience.com (Sassy) Sonya Buyting

    I hear what you’re saying about the audio vs. video podcasting. While my audio Sassy Science show (science + music = Sassy) is my bread ‘n’ butter when it comes to my online creative content, I’ve also put out one video. (Only 1 under the Sassy Science banner.) That video generates more comments than any of my audio shows do. I’ve been trying to figure out why. The video is shorter. That makes it easier to digest in a bite size chunk. It is also zany, so that could be an easy explanation. Maybe it’s the YouTube influence that makes people search out video before audio. Or maybe it’s something more shallow that make people seek out the video before audio? I don’t know.

    It still surprises me how many people don’t know that audio podcasts are essentially radio shows available on demand via the Internet. That makes me think that while the word “podcast” has reached the mainstream, many still don’t know what the heck it is. Is this bubble going to break? My hope is that if we keep pushing and if people keep buying their mp3 players, then maybe one day everyone will be downloading their favourite user created content since there’s so much great stuff out there.

    Mainstream TV is looking for the best online video delivery systems. Internet TV is taking off regardless of the mainstream. What does this mean for the future of video & audio podcasting? Who knows. Anyone?

  • http://justinkownacki.blogspot.com Justin Kownacki

    Two points:

    1) Shawn Smith of Geek Riot and I were having a similar conversation on Thursday. His take? “It seems like everyone who’s interested in new media is IN new media.” The rest of the world has yet to catch on.

    2) I’ve been approached by a union representative who’s indicated that STBD should work with them to develop a deferred payment contract for the actors. I find it ironic that I can barely afford to produce the show, yet agents of law (and commerce) are already stepping in to ensure that they get their piece of the pie, if and when there IS a pie.

    It seems a bit ludicrous to worry about employment contracts when your average New Yorker can’t name a podcast, no?

  • http://justinkownacki.blogspot.com Justin Kownacki

    Two points:

    1) Shawn Smith of Geek Riot and I were having a similar conversation on Thursday. His take? “It seems like everyone who’s interested in new media is IN new media.” The rest of the world has yet to catch on.

    2) I’ve been approached by a union representative who’s indicated that STBD should work with them to develop a deferred payment contract for the actors. I find it ironic that I can barely afford to produce the show, yet agents of law (and commerce) are already stepping in to ensure that they get their piece of the pie, if and when there IS a pie.

    It seems a bit ludicrous to worry about employment contracts when your average New Yorker can’t name a podcast, no?

  • http://www.wrestlingmayhemshow.com Michael Sorg

    While I agree with Justin and Shawn, the majority of those interested in new media seem to be in new media, it was a nice note that one of the guys from Bootcamp (that we were chopping at Bar Louie) claimed he was solely a “consumer” of podcasting and attended the event to see the nuts and bolts of what the shows he listens to go through. It was definitely a different take on the experience I was happy to see.

    I think this medium also has strong cases of people doing this content with no semblance of “stars and dollar signs” in their eyes. We’ve been doing our show for so long just because it was fun to do and we enjoyed producing it. We seemed to wake up one day and realize we had something special going on and thinking “wow, maybe we should do something more with this”.

  • http://www.wrestlingmayhemshow.com Michael Sorg

    While I agree with Justin and Shawn, the majority of those interested in new media seem to be in new media, it was a nice note that one of the guys from Bootcamp (that we were chopping at Bar Louie) claimed he was solely a “consumer” of podcasting and attended the event to see the nuts and bolts of what the shows he listens to go through. It was definitely a different take on the experience I was happy to see.

    I think this medium also has strong cases of people doing this content with no semblance of “stars and dollar signs” in their eyes. We’ve been doing our show for so long just because it was fun to do and we enjoyed producing it. We seemed to wake up one day and realize we had something special going on and thinking “wow, maybe we should do something more with this”.

  • http://Wrestlingmayhemshow.com Will Rutherford

    Outreach: A good many of our fans are people that we’ve met at wrestling shows. The fan base is out there you just have to keep an eye out for it. It can be some place obvious, (wrestling shows) or not so much (the guy at the exchange who has a wrestlemania 23 shirt on). Just keep your eyes and ears on the alert and you can find fans of just about anything.

  • http://Wrestlingmayhemshow.com Will Rutherford

    Outreach: A good many of our fans are people that we’ve met at wrestling shows. The fan base is out there you just have to keep an eye out for it. It can be some place obvious, (wrestling shows) or not so much (the guy at the exchange who has a wrestlemania 23 shirt on). Just keep your eyes and ears on the alert and you can find fans of just about anything.

  • http://www.chrishambly.com Chris Hambly

    Great post.

    It is a matter of fact I get asked, as a school, to get into video, though it is also something I have not really played with in a vlog capacity to date. Sure I’ve created plenty of mobile phone “catblogging” (filming you in the urinals springs to mind) but not any real content in a visual medium, text and audio yes tons of it, but video I have yet to tred.

    There seems to be far more engagement in video for the majority of people, and I do know that I am going to have to embrace this. I imagine next generation independent content will be similar to old broadcast empire figures in that visual is far more engaged with than audio. TV and radio as an example, not music (we all listen to music), but content in audio form is a very small niche, always has been, always will be?

    The climbing out of the fishbowl analogy is a good one, there is little point in keeping things insular, sure I love repeat visitors/listeners, I love repeat students/clients, but it is new people that we touch where we make a difference, where we change a thought process, where we show there is more than one way. It’s not even about crusading for one method, but more about providing a possibility of change, a catalyst for movement, a difference…. climbing out.

    You also use the word “rockstars” a lot, I love this and I think I agree with you that everyone is. The word rockstars is a good association for a new media creator to have, but of course a rockstar in order to stay on top must always bring in a wider audience. It’s also economies of scale right? We have to balance the books and if we do not reach out, the books will not get any bigger for us, the numbers won’t change.

  • http://www.chrishambly.com Chris Hambly

    Great post.

    It is a matter of fact I get asked, as a school, to get into video, though it is also something I have not really played with in a vlog capacity to date. Sure I’ve created plenty of mobile phone “catblogging” (filming you in the urinals springs to mind) but not any real content in a visual medium, text and audio yes tons of it, but video I have yet to tred.

    There seems to be far more engagement in video for the majority of people, and I do know that I am going to have to embrace this. I imagine next generation independent content will be similar to old broadcast empire figures in that visual is far more engaged with than audio. TV and radio as an example, not music (we all listen to music), but content in audio form is a very small niche, always has been, always will be?

    The climbing out of the fishbowl analogy is a good one, there is little point in keeping things insular, sure I love repeat visitors/listeners, I love repeat students/clients, but it is new people that we touch where we make a difference, where we change a thought process, where we show there is more than one way. It’s not even about crusading for one method, but more about providing a possibility of change, a catalyst for movement, a difference…. climbing out.

    You also use the word “rockstars” a lot, I love this and I think I agree with you that everyone is. The word rockstars is a good association for a new media creator to have, but of course a rockstar in order to stay on top must always bring in a wider audience. It’s also economies of scale right? We have to balance the books and if we do not reach out, the books will not get any bigger for us, the numbers won’t change.

  • Pingback: Christopher S. Penn » Blog Archive » Scaling the Clear Walls

  • http://www.ldpodcast.com Whitney

    I still think podcasting is still a new medium, and the adoption curve by the general public is still behind- what’s sad, i we of little attention span are ready to change formats, try new things and do whatever we think will garner more attention, when it can be something as simple as Justin’s BootCamp, or talkng to friends at lunch about how to get a podcast- reaching out to all those real world friends- the “wrinkly’s”- make your parents and their friends your listeners as well- your evangelists. They have disposable income, smarts, but timidity about how to use new media tools, and haven’t grasped the impact it can have on them- they assume its another teenage fad.
    We need to use the “You Don’t Need an ipod” song and video to maximum effect- anyone up for picking a day and we all do a Bum Rush sort of deal with “You Don’t need an ipod”? Maybe no money allowed, but sure as heck might get some attention to that “ipod thing”.
    Just a thought.

  • http://www.ldpodcast.com Whitney

    I still think podcasting is still a new medium, and the adoption curve by the general public is still behind- what’s sad, i we of little attention span are ready to change formats, try new things and do whatever we think will garner more attention, when it can be something as simple as Justin’s BootCamp, or talkng to friends at lunch about how to get a podcast- reaching out to all those real world friends- the “wrinkly’s”- make your parents and their friends your listeners as well- your evangelists. They have disposable income, smarts, but timidity about how to use new media tools, and haven’t grasped the impact it can have on them- they assume its another teenage fad.
    We need to use the “You Don’t Need an ipod” song and video to maximum effect- anyone up for picking a day and we all do a Bum Rush sort of deal with “You Don’t need an ipod”? Maybe no money allowed, but sure as heck might get some attention to that “ipod thing”.
    Just a thought.

  • Pingback: globalburger.net » Blog Archive » Episodes, Fishbowls, and Vancouver

  • http://www.Lx7.ca Vergel Evans

    I think if anything… the zine culture from the punk days needs to come back. Printing out some of your blog entries, show topics etc. add a cover and hand it out at events where ppl who would likely consume your content would be….

    I’ve been doing that for my podcast with my fanzine (http://www.assembler.tv) The zine has easily driven more traffic back to the show then any forum posting. Taking the time to promote and share knowledge in a more world readable format has made something that could be considered disposable, a collectible.

    Long live fanzine culture….

  • http://www.Lx7.ca Vergel Evans

    I think if anything… the zine culture from the punk days needs to come back. Printing out some of your blog entries, show topics etc. add a cover and hand it out at events where ppl who would likely consume your content would be….

    I’ve been doing that for my podcast with my fanzine (http://www.assembler.tv) The zine has easily driven more traffic back to the show then any forum posting. Taking the time to promote and share knowledge in a more world readable format has made something that could be considered disposable, a collectible.

    Long live fanzine culture….

  • Pingback: On the road - reflections on the fishbowl « Levite Chronicles