Google Launches AdSense for Feeds- Breaks My Subscriber Count

googlefail As I’m reading everywhere, people woke up to the ability to monetize their RSS feed with Google AdSense instead of FeedBurner (my friends from Chicago). Great, except on the day that you launched, I’ve magically lost about 3,000 RSS subscribers. Coincidence? I’m thinking no, but hey, maybe I’m just not being a good citizen about it.

**Update: and in other news, Technorati just shifted their numbers dramatically, too. I do check in on my Technorati ranking, and this morning, I was 377. Not bad, eh? But this afternoon, not far after the Google experience, I just looked in there:

technoratifail

What’s up with this? Part of me feels like Obi Wan Kenobi: “I feel a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in terror, and were suddenly silenced.”

I want my 3,000 friends back, please. Don’t be the new definition of the failwhale.

King Failwhale has a Beer

ChrisBrogan.com runs on the Genesis Framework

Genesis Theme Framework

The Genesis Framework empowers you to quickly and easily build incredible websites with WordPress. Whether you're a novice or advanced developer, Genesis provides you with the secure and search-engine-optimized foundation that takes WordPress to places you never thought it could go.

With automatic theme updates and world-class support included, Genesis is the smart choice for your WordPress website or blog.

Become a StudioPress Affiliate

  • http://pixelrn.com Beth

    At least they only halved yours. Mine are gone completely and no one is replying to my message on the “help” board.

  • http://pixelrn.com Beth

    At least they only halved yours. Mine are gone completely and no one is replying to my message on the “help” board.

  • http://www.charlesheflin.com Charles Heflin

    Oh no … this is not good. I wonder if anyone else has experienced this. I for one will not put AdSense on my feeds. I think that many people will be annoyed with them.

    You must be getting slammed with traffic. Took forever for your blog to load.

    Charles Heflin
    Twitter @CharlesHeflin

  • http://www.charlesheflin.com Charles Heflin

    Oh no … this is not good. I wonder if anyone else has experienced this. I for one will not put AdSense on my feeds. I think that many people will be annoyed with them.

    You must be getting slammed with traffic. Took forever for your blog to load.

    Charles Heflin
    Twitter @CharlesHeflin

  • http://pixelrn.com Beth

    At least they only halved yours. Mine are gone completely and no one is replying to my message on the “help” board.

  • http://www.charlesheflin.com Charles Heflin

    Oh no … this is not good. I wonder if anyone else has experienced this. I for one will not put AdSense on my feeds. I think that many people will be annoyed with them.

    You must be getting slammed with traffic. Took forever for your blog to load.

    Charles Heflin
    Twitter @CharlesHeflin

  • http://richardkannegieser.com Richard Kannegieser

    Wow….they really did it this time! Messing with people’s subscribers! And it’s happening to more than one person yikes!
    Google and its spam always messing something up! I think that just like adsense, its just tacky and annoying! I agree with Charles on the the slow site loading! You must be swamped!

  • http://richardkannegieser.com Richard Kannegieser

    Wow….they really did it this time! Messing with people’s subscribers! And it’s happening to more than one person yikes!
    Google and its spam always messing something up! I think that just like adsense, its just tacky and annoying! I agree with Charles on the the slow site loading! You must be swamped!

  • http://richardkannegieser.com Richard Kannegieser

    Wow….they really did it this time! Messing with people’s subscribers! And it’s happening to more than one person yikes!
    Google and its spam always messing something up! I think that just like adsense, its just tacky and annoying! I agree with Charles on the the slow site loading! You must be swamped!

  • http://www.portagemedia.com Jeremiah Staes

    Could it be – and this is just speculation, Chris – that with the new system stricter rules for what actually constitutes a subscriber were implemented (or somehow the tracking changed), lowering the numbers?

  • http://www.portagemedia.com Jeremiah Staes

    Could it be – and this is just speculation, Chris – that with the new system stricter rules for what actually constitutes a subscriber were implemented (or somehow the tracking changed), lowering the numbers?

  • http://www.portagemedia.com Jeremiah Staes

    Could it be – and this is just speculation, Chris – that with the new system stricter rules for what actually constitutes a subscriber were implemented (or somehow the tracking changed), lowering the numbers?

  • http://theprogressbar.com Dave Evans

    I lost 20% of my subscribers overnight, boo!

  • http://theprogressbar.com Dave Evans

    I lost 20% of my subscribers overnight, boo!

  • http://theprogressbar.com Dave Evans

    I lost 20% of my subscribers overnight, boo!

  • http://reachingforlucidity.net Eban Crawford

    Normally I try to add to the original thought when I comment, but in this case, well, Dude, that sucks.

    Nothing like fixing things that are not broken, and breaking them in the process.

    Hope that is just a glitch with the switch. (rhyme unintentional)

    Noe I am going to check my stats.

  • http://reachingforlucidity.net Eban Crawford

    Normally I try to add to the original thought when I comment, but in this case, well, Dude, that sucks.

    Nothing like fixing things that are not broken, and breaking them in the process.

    Hope that is just a glitch with the switch. (rhyme unintentional)

    Noe I am going to check my stats.

  • http://reachingforlucidity.net Eban Crawford

    Normally I try to add to the original thought when I comment, but in this case, well, Dude, that sucks.

    Nothing like fixing things that are not broken, and breaking them in the process.

    Hope that is just a glitch with the switch. (rhyme unintentional)

    Noe I am going to check my stats.

  • http://sharonsreport.blogspot.com/ Sharon Rosen

    At one point yesterday my subscriber count went to zero, and although I now show subscribers again, I lost quite a few. I do NOT have ads on my feed at this time, so I wonder what happened. My post from this morning never turned into a feed either…

  • http://sharonsreport.blogspot.com/ Sharon Rosen

    At one point yesterday my subscriber count went to zero, and although I now show subscribers again, I lost quite a few. I do NOT have ads on my feed at this time, so I wonder what happened. My post from this morning never turned into a feed either…

  • http://Blog.HubSpot.com Mike Volpe – HubSpot

    We lost an even greater percentage on the HubSpot blog. We were over 4000, and today it is showing at under 2500. Supposedly it is not counting all the people subscribed by Google Reader, which is a big number.

    Feedburner is not a business class service, like many free/web2.0 apps (as we recently learned with a multi-hour Gmail outage) and we all know about Twitter…

  • http://Blog.HubSpot.com Mike Volpe – HubSpot

    We lost an even greater percentage on the HubSpot blog. We were over 4000, and today it is showing at under 2500. Supposedly it is not counting all the people subscribed by Google Reader, which is a big number.

    Feedburner is not a business class service, like many free/web2.0 apps (as we recently learned with a multi-hour Gmail outage) and we all know about Twitter…

  • http://Blog.HubSpot.com Mike Volpe – HubSpot

    We lost an even greater percentage on the HubSpot blog. We were over 4000, and today it is showing at under 2500. Supposedly it is not counting all the people subscribed by Google Reader, which is a big number.

    Feedburner is not a business class service, like many free/web2.0 apps (as we recently learned with a multi-hour Gmail outage) and we all know about Twitter…

  • http://internetjogging.com Cawlin

    I lost close to half my subscribers overnight!

    crap.

  • http://internetjogging.com Cawlin

    I lost close to half my subscribers overnight!

    crap.

  • http://internetjogging.com Cawlin

    I lost close to half my subscribers overnight!

    crap.

  • http://www.jugglingfrogs.com Juggling Frogs

    I also don’t have ads on my feeds, but lost about 33% in a growing-traffic and stumble-full week.

    I started to worry that I did or said something recently that made a bunch of people annoyed or offended. Or that a recent post I’ve been editing and re-editing was showing up over and over in other peoples feeds. (But I’m subscribed to my own feed and didn’t see it, so figured that that was paranoia)

    Thank you for mentioning it. It’s like a global Google Gaslight treatment!

  • http://www.jugglingfrogs.com Juggling Frogs

    I also don’t have ads on my feeds, but lost about 33% in a growing-traffic and stumble-full week.

    I started to worry that I did or said something recently that made a bunch of people annoyed or offended. Or that a recent post I’ve been editing and re-editing was showing up over and over in other peoples feeds. (But I’m subscribed to my own feed and didn’t see it, so figured that that was paranoia)

    Thank you for mentioning it. It’s like a global Google Gaslight treatment!

  • http://www.jugglingfrogs.com Juggling Frogs

    I also don’t have ads on my feeds, but lost about 33% in a growing-traffic and stumble-full week.

    I started to worry that I did or said something recently that made a bunch of people annoyed or offended. Or that a recent post I’ve been editing and re-editing was showing up over and over in other peoples feeds. (But I’m subscribed to my own feed and didn’t see it, so figured that that was paranoia)

    Thank you for mentioning it. It’s like a global Google Gaslight treatment!

  • Pingback: RichardKannegieser.com » Google is stealing your RSS Subscribers!

  • http://thefuturebuzz.com Adam Singer

    I lost 1/3 of my subscribers as well — lost a good 100! not cool =(

  • http://thefuturebuzz.com Adam Singer

    I lost 1/3 of my subscribers as well — lost a good 100! not cool =(

  • http://thefuturebuzz.com Adam Singer

    I lost 1/3 of my subscribers as well — lost a good 100! not cool =(

  • http://www.technotheory.com Jared Goralnick

    Shoot! Me too! I lost about a third (31%) of my subscribers. I wonder if it was a separate update and the numbers are more accurate…or just a huge fail.

    Thanks for aggregating some of our experiences here, hopefully we can get an explanation soon.

  • http://www.technotheory.com Jared Goralnick

    Shoot! Me too! I lost about a third (31%) of my subscribers. I wonder if it was a separate update and the numbers are more accurate…or just a huge fail.

    Thanks for aggregating some of our experiences here, hopefully we can get an explanation soon.

  • http://www.technotheory.com Jared Goralnick

    Shoot! Me too! I lost about a third (31%) of my subscribers. I wonder if it was a separate update and the numbers are more accurate…or just a huge fail.

    Thanks for aggregating some of our experiences here, hopefully we can get an explanation soon.

  • http://www.mediabadger.com Webconomist

    We had a couple of clients call who noticed this and weren’t amused, we lost a few off feedburner as well…one can only hope a glitch?

  • http://www.mediabadger.com Webconomist

    We had a couple of clients call who noticed this and weren’t amused, we lost a few off feedburner as well…one can only hope a glitch?

  • http://www.mediabadger.com Webconomist

    We had a couple of clients call who noticed this and weren’t amused, we lost a few off feedburner as well…one can only hope a glitch?

  • http://writerdad.com Writer Dad

    I lost most of my subscribers too. Sigh.

  • http://writerdad.com Writer Dad

    I lost most of my subscribers too. Sigh.

  • http://writerdad.com Writer Dad

    I lost most of my subscribers too. Sigh.

  • http://technologyinprevention.blogspot.com LaDonna Coy

    This is too frustrating … while my subscriber list is quite small in comparison to most here – I still would like to keep them! Bottom line, I lost everyone Monday morning, got them back Monday evening and now lost half of them again today. Now sitting here wondering … can I trust the data I see on Feedburner at any given point? What’s real? What can I count on?

  • http://technologyinprevention.blogspot.com LaDonna Coy

    This is too frustrating … while my subscriber list is quite small in comparison to most here – I still would like to keep them! Bottom line, I lost everyone Monday morning, got them back Monday evening and now lost half of them again today. Now sitting here wondering … can I trust the data I see on Feedburner at any given point? What’s real? What can I count on?

  • http://technologyinprevention.blogspot.com LaDonna Coy

    This is too frustrating … while my subscriber list is quite small in comparison to most here – I still would like to keep them! Bottom line, I lost everyone Monday morning, got them back Monday evening and now lost half of them again today. Now sitting here wondering … can I trust the data I see on Feedburner at any given point? What’s real? What can I count on?

  • http://www.mynameiskate.ca Kate Trgovac

    Yep .. we lost some too. About 35% on onedegree.ca; almost 50% on mynameiskate.ca And we’re not using the feedburner ads.

    I think Google must be having a major shift in a lot of areas. A few sites I have that had been getting page 1 keyword ranks and PR’s of 5 or 6 have been kicked out of Google or dropped to about page 10 of ranks plus now have PR’s of 0.

    Is it the Apocalypse? Is the world shifting? Haven’t even bothered to check Technorati – am just starting my Friday happy hour much much earlier.

  • http://www.mynameiskate.ca Kate Trgovac

    Yep .. we lost some too. About 35% on onedegree.ca; almost 50% on mynameiskate.ca And we’re not using the feedburner ads.

    I think Google must be having a major shift in a lot of areas. A few sites I have that had been getting page 1 keyword ranks and PR’s of 5 or 6 have been kicked out of Google or dropped to about page 10 of ranks plus now have PR’s of 0.

    Is it the Apocalypse? Is the world shifting? Haven’t even bothered to check Technorati – am just starting my Friday happy hour much much earlier.

  • http://www.mynameiskate.ca Kate Trgovac

    Yep .. we lost some too. About 35% on onedegree.ca; almost 50% on mynameiskate.ca And we’re not using the feedburner ads.

    I think Google must be having a major shift in a lot of areas. A few sites I have that had been getting page 1 keyword ranks and PR’s of 5 or 6 have been kicked out of Google or dropped to about page 10 of ranks plus now have PR’s of 0.

    Is it the Apocalypse? Is the world shifting? Haven’t even bothered to check Technorati – am just starting my Friday happy hour much much earlier.

  • http://www.azhttp.com/ Bill Austin

    One of my feeds went from 12795 to 217.

  • http://www.azhttp.com/ Bill Austin

    One of my feeds went from 12795 to 217.

GetSocial