Let Them MAKE Cake

Chris, this is a brilliant summary and illustration of what this stuff’s all about!

Joanna

PS Don’t be too hard on yourself – you are blazing a trail for the rest of us, don’t forget

Very nice.

Thank you for the excellent metaphor about how to encourage participation.

Your point about media, I think, is bang on. The cake analogy, however, might be a bit of a stretch. I suspect that it has to do with consumers/bakers feeling that a mix that requires actual ingredients would produce a higher quality result.

But media: yes, there’s a better ROI when it’s participatory.

There are sort of two points in one here. One is that people like to feel wanted. Doing something makes people feel wanted. The other point is that by buttoning up your media too tightly, people don’t have anything to add, no participation.

The reason movies (and books) have “entry characters,” those characters that give us a perspective of this all being new and gee whiz (Think Harry Potter as the new non-muggle on the block), is so that YOU, as reader, can feel part of this new world and participate in it.

Thus, if we lift that premise, our media needs to have the same feel.

Make sense?

There are sort of two points in one here. One is that people like to feel wanted. Doing something makes people feel wanted. The other point is that by buttoning up your media too tightly, people don’t have anything to add, no participation.

The reason movies (and books) have “entry characters,” those characters that give us a perspective of this all being new and gee whiz (Think Harry Potter as the new non-muggle on the block), is so that YOU, as reader, can feel part of this new world and participate in it.

Thus, if we lift that premise, our media needs to have the same feel.

Make sense?

excellent!!!!

Hey Chris – I was excited to read this short post (well, the cake pic reeled me in. Ha ha.)

I’m guessing you’ve seen the incredible BBC series “Century of Self” that reveals the work of Edward Bernays (Freud’s nephew). It was indeed Betty Crocker that introduced instant cake mix as a convenience food in the early ’50s, but it wasn’t until consumers were instructed to add an egg that sales resumed. Yep, participation is key!!

See:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-678466363224520614
at min 21:49 if you’re interested!

Chris,

I think this analogy needs a bit of work, I’m afraid.

A generation previously, cake-mix had appealed to those who wanted “time saving”… because it was quicker than just starting with a bunch of ingredients (in the way their mothers [and I use the gender-specific language with 99% accuracy if you look at cakes baked in the 1950].)

… by the time the incident you described happened, it was READY-MADE cakes that were the convenience-led mass market buy.

Cakemix had changed its positioning to the segment who wanted a “cake-making experience” rather than the people who wanted a cake. It was no longer about being the quick way to have a cake… it was about those who wanted to feel involved.

Most people didn’t want to feel involved – they just wanted the sugar rush that came with EATING the cake rather than a close personal relationship with the cake-maker.

Where the manufacturers of cake-mix were failing was that they were still thinking in terms of the OLD niche – but were so close to the product that they thought “how do we make cake-making easier” rather than “how do we make cake-getting easier.”

And that, in a nutshell, is one of the hard points of Web 2.0….

…. there are SOME who want to get involved, and help bake the cake…

… there are many more who want a quick cake fix, and have no interest in baking whatsoever.

Web2.0 seems to assume that the world is full of cake-bakers.

I guess that the interesting point is that, it would turn out, that some of the amateur cake-bakers (bloggers, say) have ended up making more popular cakes (blogs) than the so-called professional chefs (journalists.)

Regardless of the specific history, I think this is a fantastic metaphor.

You are so right. I own a bakery and indeed, people want to be involved in putting it together…eggs and all! Good thinking. Keep going!

This is quite impressive, I am pleased to read this post, keep posts like this coming, you totally rock!
sain-web.com

Chris – excellent snapshot

Very good… thanks for the nice metaphor.

Not going up high, but sufficient practical, Never pursuing fashion, but in every day.Thisbasketball shoes outlet
is so simple, fashion, classic,helping your home more pretty indeed! I know there's a shop selling many in this style, you can also see again if there have more beautiful
you like