What Nine Inch Nails Knows About Tribes

April 16, 2009 · Comments

Street Busker in Wellington New Zealand This week, I watched Siobhan Bulfin birth a new tribe around her. ( I’ll use Seth’s word for it, though I go back and forth on the analogy I prefer.) The seeds planted at Marketing Now will surely bloom into a small community of people who care about each other and who will help each other develop new voices in the new media and marketing spaces.

She has started a tribe. What I’m excited about is how some new technologies (and some that we’ve already been using) will enable even more useful interactions. I’m particularly excited by what Nine Inch Nails have done (more below).

Last week, I saw community building in Detroit. The week before, I was at the heart of it in Southern California. In all of these places, little tribes formed around thoughtful leaders. They are intentional communities. Seth taught me a bit about the leader’s role in all this. In fact, while reading the advanced copy of Tribes on the side of a lake while my daughter took swim lessons, I read the part where Seth told us that all tribes needed a leader. It was the subtitle of the book, actually: “we need you to lead us.”

True story: when the point Seth was making sank in, I emailed him and said something very much like, “You bastard. You’ve just explained several of my own personal failures of the last few years.” He did.

The thing was, I was trying to build autonomous communities, where I felt they could run themselves. I tried it with several of my projects starting in 2006. I’d build something, get a bunch of people excited, and try to let it go to the wild. Every time, it would falter almost at once, no matter how passionate people were. Transferring ownership was never the same as finding a leader. (Again, nothing bad about the people involved, and everything bad about my inability to understand this point).

What’s Next: nin:access

I am blown away by nin:access, the iPhone application for Nine Inch Nails fans. On the surface, it’s not immediately obvious why it’s sexy. Here’s what they say about it:

  • Exchange messages and photos with other NIN fans in your neighborhood and around the world

  • Access NIN news, photos, custom wallpapers, and your nin.com inbox

Here’s a few screen captures:

main screen

location-based

Look at that second one. Location-based. It is a listing (opt-in) of fans of Nine Inch Nails geographically, so that you can, should you wish, connect up with other fans in an area. (Yes, I know that the example text isn’t all that enlightened, but think beyond what you see.)

You Can Have It All

Trent Reznor and Nine Inch Nails have it figured out. Empower fan-to-fan interaction. They’ve had that with their message boards, with their nin.com mail service, with all their other actions over the last years. But with the location-enabled iPhone app, it just feels even more super powered.

You can do this, too. There’s not a lot of super high end tech in what they did (not dissing NIN). It’s just good marketing for a great community. Not ready to plunk down some money on an iPhone app that will do this? You could always use BrightKite as a starting point to understanding what it’ll do for you. (If you want to build an iPhone app that does this, I could get that done for you.)

Location plus peer-to-peer interactions = a huge win.

A Quick Community Checklist

What if you’re Siobhan Bulfin or someone else looking to empower a little community of intent? What would be a way to do it? Here’s a quick little roadmap that might be useful:

  • Name the Community Something Inclusive. (In the case of Nine Inch Nails, they’ve self-selected to gather around the band. Sometimes, it’s not as easy to make it about a product or company. Find a name that folks feel like they can own, something they can put on a flag of their own and hoist high (if that makes sense).
  • Buy the URL for that name or something close.
  • Make sure you understand the value to your prospective members for joining the community. Are you an information-sharing site, a business networking group, a creativity group? What are the ways in which everyone will be able to participate and contribute? What’s the “fire” that you’re gathering around? ( This is the “Channels vs. Communities argument that Stephen Saber makes.)
  • Start with a simple Ning community, if you expect your group to be fairly small and if you don’t need high end power community tools.
  • Put up a Flickr group so that there’s a place to put community photos.
  • Think up a few meaningful tags that people can apply to any media, should they want to write about your group, the events, whatever as it relates.
  • Start an email list by asking folks to opt in. Email marketing is still very successful in building community and driving relations. If you want everyone to have the ability to mail the group, consider using a simple service like YahooGroups for people to opt into to receive messages.
  • Would a location-based tool like BrightKite be useful?
  • Should you hold Tweetups?
  • Do people want to publish a shared list of users on other social services, like Twitter and/or LinkedIn?
  • Find ways to deliver value.
  • Find ways to deliver more value.
  • Find ways to encourage participation (another blog post in its own right).
  • Find ways to gather the tribe around your various issues of interest.
  • Find ways to facilitate peer-to-peer sharing, as well as member-driven media making.
  • Lather. Rinse. Repeat.

I’m encouraged by the “nin:access” application released by Nine Inch Nails. It points towards another way to enable communities of passion. I think there’s great value in building around these ideas, and that there’s much more to be done here in this space.

What’s your take? Does the above list help? What other elements have you built into your community building?

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

ChrisBrogan.com runs on the Thesis Theme for WordPress

Thesis WordPress theme

Thesis is the search engine optimized WordPress theme of choice for serious online publishers. If you’re a blogger who doesn’t understand a lot of PHP, Thesis will give a ton of functionality without having to alter any code. For the advanced, Thesis has incredible customization possibilities via Thesis hooks.

With so many design options, you can use the template over and over and never have it look like the same site. The theme is robust and flexible enough not only to accommodate a site like ChrisBrogan.com, but also to enable the site to run far more efficiently than it ever has before.

  • These are good community basics, well applied by NIN. How quickly we overlook thins like this. Heck, even for a personal brand, making it easy for your fans to find each other and connect and share is key.

    What about your brand Chris?
  • NiN have always been pushing the new music business model forward, and I've always been a fan of Renor's actions (many a blog post here - http://www.leejarvis.blogspot.com).

    Nice of you to bring his good work to an audience here, Chris, and it could certainly be applied to many a business or community in other areas. If there were a few more influential people in the music industry who thought the same as Reznor then maybe it wouldn't be in such a mess right now!
  • Sweet niblets, Chris! How many great realizations can you sneak into one post?

    I have to agree, as much as some recent noise is being made about how minimally important the leader is to established organizations, I'm still not convinced. My personal experience starting, running and trying to hand-off companies and observations (spelled "Apple, Nike & Starbucks") tell me otherwise.

    And, yup, I'm really excited to see how apps that enable likeminded people to spontaneously congregate will change the dynamic of tribe-building and afford crowdsourced deputization of local tribe sub-leaders.
  • Thanks too for sharing a learning from Tribes. Leaders really do need to lead. I'm involved in a couple communities where my role is to politely jab, cajole, nudge and otherwise get people in the group to interact and build things. Without the leader actually leading, it fades.

    I used to wonder whether the community was 'worth it' if it didn't take off on its own accord, without leaders keeping things moving. These days I'm thinking more that the leader is a required part of the equation.
  • Nine Inch Nails has always been a step ahead of the game, in my opinion, of rallying their fans together on the internet. Long before forums were popular, they had a very unique forum, and then they had their access site. So it doesn't surprise me that they have come out with this. They are great at keeping fans up to date with the latest technology.

    ~ Kristi
  • I believe that the NIN case is really one to study throughoutly. Reznor said himself he makes way more money doing shows than selling albums, so all of his efforts are obviously directed at making his public grow. While most bands would make sure they shut down projects like http://thisoneisonus.org (a community-created DVD), they actually increased the ammount of material people have available to work with.

    Increasing the band's exposure with minimum expendure is what's making NIN thrive. They couldn't do it without this tribe Trent created around him.
  • Chris,
    Thank you for your thoughts on Tribes. I just started to read Seth's book myself. I am interested in the brightkite / location based app myself for a Tribe I am leading. How can I get that done? Looking forward to reading your Blog daily, and will forward to all of my colleagues. have a great weekend.

    Drew Griffin
  • It's not a tweet-up per se, but I know a few of us who are using the NIN:Access app in the Philly area are getting together for drinks tonight.
  • Chris,
    I enjoyed reading your post as well as the ideas of others who contributed. Great Stuff ! Love the community check list as it provokes more creative thinking on my part. An important component to building any great community is storytelling. Sharing your own personal story to start this post drew a YEA! from me. Finally love discussion on LEADERSHIP. Technology is cool, a critical tool etc. but in the end we are trying to influence and in some cases lead people. That involves emotional intelligence part of transformational leadership. Thanks
    Bill
  • For all the things going wrong within the music industry, NIN has been THE beacon of light that every music executive should be paying attention too. Just another good reason why I love NIN.

    Love it, and what a great post!!
  • Great stuff here Chris.

    You should check out our Group Blogging Project that we're doing covering Tribes: http://churchcrunch.com/2009/04/13/tribes-a-gro...
  • Empowering fan-to-fan interaction is exactly what I want my art to lead to, my way of taking over the world, connecting people with their music, their culture, and their humanity.

    Peace.
  • Great post Chris.

    My husband was showing me their app last night. It is very sleek and well thought out. I imagine we will see similar apps hitting the mobile market soon. This one is brilliant.
  • Chris,

    Reminds me of the story about the band, Linkin' Park and their web success.

    Mike Shinoda at BlogWorld Expo 2008 Keynote with Timothy Ferris and Rohit Bhargava stated that Twitter and MySpace were the cause of Linkin' Park receiving a recording contract with Warner Brothers Records.

    Mike stated that their fans put so much pressure on Warner's they had to sign up the band. He also stated that you can now distribute your own music and do not need a recording contract at all!

    NOTE: (They named the band Linkin' Park after Lincoln Park in East Los Angeles CA, and Lincoln Park had already been taken!).

    Great story about NIN, a talented band using technology to connect with people, a theme you have consistently forwarded, it's about the people!

    Respectfully,

    Nicholas Chase
    www.twitter.com/nachase
  • Chris,

    Some great insights you are sharing with your own tribe. Love the checklist and think you are spot on. Keep up the great work.

    @MaikelvandeMort
  • This is powerful marketing stuff. The music industry should be sitting up, taking note and being even more scared.
  • I agree. NIN has been ahead of the curve for a very long time with many innovative community building efforts. What makes them different isnt really the tech, like you said, but its the care they have for their own community and how they want to foster it to grow on its own.

    I've been thinking about NIN, the music industry and its death, and social media. Here's a couple posts. http://jesskrywosa.wordpress.com/tag/nin/

    If the music industry hopes to survive it needs to think this way. It cant continue to manipulate artists, contracts and consumers to wring every last cent of profit for themselves. Its not a secret that artists have had a bum deal, but by creating these mobile and social communities, Reznor has brought to light the manipulation of the consumer - something the less powerful or savvy artist may have no control over.

    Its great that someone like NIN, with such a cult following, who dont have to be thoughtful of fans are really the ones taking on this type of politics. Tori Amos is another example, but more focused on innovative limited offerings (comic books, art, etc.).

    And that was my music industry soap box. Sorry! As always, loved the post. :)

    @jesskry
  • If Chris Brogan were a rock band, I'd be a groupie. :)

    I can relate to the feeling of trying to get a community to stand on its own ... to set it up with the members and tools needed to keep it self-generating ... and then to watch it fizzle out like a pathetic little campfire in the middle of a "Survivor" hurricane. So sad. So frustrating.

    Your shared realization that each "tribe" or community needs a leader is especially enlightening for me. There are some user-generated communities that take on a life of their own, but for the most part a community isn't something you can start up and walk away from - it's an extension of your passion and it needs to feed off your passion to stay alive.

    Some other things I would consider when starting a community:
    * Research where potential members of your tribe might be hanging out now - get a feel for what's already available to these people ...and what's missing
    * Create an "elevator pitch"-like summary of what your community is all about. Although this can be modified as your tribe and reason for existence evolves, it's important for you (and "your people") to have a clear vision of what your tribe is all about - it helps to make the group more cohesive.
    * In addition to the URL, set up a twitter profile and maybe a facebook page - both places can be great ways to recruit and keep in touch with members.
    * Think about ways you can give back. If you're about equestrian sports, maybe help support an equine rescue; if your about literature, maybe support a literary grant program. Giving back is a great bonding tool for groups large and small ... and it's good karma and a great use of social tools. :)

    These spill over into the "encourage participation" area, but have bearing on your community set-up.
    * Make it EASY for people to engage - consider polls and other "quickie" response items to get people involved right away.
    * Make sure you have a way to RSS (or otherwise publish) community activity to people's readers and/or email ... and then encourage them to use it.

    And now I'm going to shut my trap. ;)
    Thanks for another great post, Chris. Have a GREAT Friday!
  • Simon Pleasants
    Hi Chris,

    English prog rock band Marillion have been doing something similar too. Check out the Marillion Convention idea where the band comandeers an entire holiday camp site (such as Butlins) for their devoted fans to enjoy a whole weekend of performances: http://www.marillion.com/
  • Mary Eppele aka StarryNightDiv
    Chris Brogan SO rocks :)
  • Check out 12for12k for the ultimate tribe:

    http://12for12k.org

    Everybody wins.
  • thanks Chris. You sure have a tribe now and it's successful because you empower it everyday with a post of value with insights which stem from an inquiring mind, unblinkered vision and a desire to draw the best out of your readers and enable them to succeed despite their means.
    Bravo to you. And amen to technology which has allowed us to access mentors, information and opportunities our parents could only have dreamed of.

    Siobhan Bulfin
    Wellington, New Zealand
  • Brandon Chesnutt
    Chris,

    This is awesome list of tips for those seeking to build, empower, inspire and grow a new community. It is also a great complement to the advice you gave me at #module09: gather and collaborate, learn everything you can and then embed that knowledge within other groups.

    We have a lot of passionate people here in Detroit with a lot of great ideas. Hopefully by the next time you pay us a visit, our own "roadmap" will be in place.

    And I'm glad you checked out the NIN app! When I first saw the demo, I knew it would be something special...and not just because I love Nine Inch Nails.

    One other thing to note: the app is FREE!
  • Jacquelyn Pierce
    Great stuff Chris, thanks for the insight! Fundamentally people want to connect and are motivated by like-mindedness or pain. It's the human element that gives us the true high of connection. Technology should be the vehicle not the destination.
  • One of things that stand out here is the need for a community to care about each other.

    And (noticing my Twitter Tribe - which isn't everyone I follow) that can grow from regular contact with people.

    I also agree that some leadership can be really important - people are so busy that there needs to be some forward-moving energy to keep momentum going against the natural inertia of daily life.
  • What a great post, Chris. I read Tribes several times (listening to it on MP3) and I think I got it, but your post illuminated a direction to take. The tribe I want to help are readers of horror fiction. The publisher of Delirium Book (an independent horror publisher) and creator of the Horror Mall (an online seller of horror books, DVDs and ebooks) recently created The Haunt -- like a simplified MySpace for horror enthusiasts. That's a community and a tribe -- and I've been wondering if someone should step up and lead them. Your post has given me something to think about.
    --Greg
  • mcmost1
    Chris, nice breakdown for folks that are interested in starting out their own community. TReznor has been experimental with his music and technology, that goes w/o saying and I would say the guy will continue to tap whatever new comes along. My only wish is that he releases Strobe Light the April Fool's album though :) http://www.nin.com/strobelight/
  • WOW ... that is a great move and interesting to see a music group pull it off. I wouldn't think this would even be on their radar. HUGE kudos for being a front runner in this space. Now i want to see NIN do a Tweetup ... once that happens Twitter has arrived :)

    Location based and community building ... very cool. Chris what i really appreciate about reading posts like this is the fact that it makes me think about my own business/customers. I always get new ideas, insight and inspiration.

    Chris ... really ... this is another post that makes me think about uses for things like this in the nonprofit space. What type of organization, event, cause do you think this type of app could work with? where would it have some legs?

    http://twitter.com/franswaa
  • Great list Chris!

    A lot can be learned from the Hippies (both older and younger) who have always championed the tribe philosophy and local community organizing.

    Now that Matt Lauer is no longer doing his travel series, it's fun to see where you're off to next!

    Cheers!
    James
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: